dc.contributor.author | Bourne, Craig | |
dc.contributor.author | Caddick Bourne, Emily | |
dc.date.accessioned | 2013-11-13T09:31:08Z | |
dc.date.available | 2013-11-13T09:31:08Z | |
dc.date.issued | 2013 | |
dc.identifier.citation | Bourne , C & Caddick Bourne , E 2013 ' Does same-sex marriage show Church and state cannot sing from the same hymn sheet? ' University of Hertfordshire . | |
dc.identifier.other | PURE: 2538703 | |
dc.identifier.other | PURE UUID: 28afd750-b70d-4dfa-a761-c029c1279a3e | |
dc.identifier.other | ORCID: /0000-0002-4980-8911/work/32558773 | |
dc.identifier.uri | http://hdl.handle.net/2299/12109 | |
dc.description.abstract | One important conflict between Church and state in which there is much contemporary interest centres on same-sex marriage. More and more states are reforming marriage law to allow for same-sex marriage in the secular context. The extension of equal marriage from the secular to the religious context, however, remains fraught. We respond to three arguments against same-sex marriage within religious contexts. The first says that same-sex relationships fail to realise the value of marriage because they do not lead to procreation. The second says that the attitudes expressed in a religious text justify not accommodating same-sex marriage. The third says that making marriage available to same-sex couples induces a change in the meaning of ‘marriage’. We argue that none of these arguments succeeds. Religious representatives should, if they are open to reasons (see §3), endorse same-sex marriage. Nevertheless, we argue that the state should allow individuals who perform religious marriages the option of declining to marry same-sex couples. This is because of the special role of sincerity in performing a marriage. The requirement of sincerity distinguishes the case of marriage from cases where a couple’s right to equality of opportunity is violated, e.g. where an hotelier refuses a room to a couple because they are of the same sex. Representatives of a religion who believe that marriage is unsuitable for same-sex couples, however poor their arguments, are incapable of performing same-sex marriages. In that case, they should not be subject to state sanctions for refusing to marry a same-sex couple. | en |
dc.format.extent | 28 | |
dc.language.iso | eng | |
dc.publisher | University of Hertfordshire | |
dc.rights | Open | |
dc.title | Does same-sex marriage show Church and state cannot sing from the same hymn sheet? | en |
dc.contributor.institution | Philosophy | |
dc.contributor.institution | School of Humanities | |
dc.contributor.institution | Social Sciences, Arts & Humanities Research Institute | |
dc.contributor.institution | Law | |
dc.relation.school | School of Humanities | |
dc.description.versiontype | Final Published version | |
dcterms.dateAccepted | 2013 | |
rioxxterms.version | VoR | |
rioxxterms.type | Working paper | |
herts.preservation.rarelyaccessed | true | |
herts.rights.accesstype | Open | |