The Expert Patients Programme: a paradox of patient empowerment and medical dominance
Author
Wilson, P.M.
Kendall, S.
Brooks, F.
Attention
2299/1979
Abstract
Self-care is seen as a key element in managing resource demand in chronic disease and is also perceived as an empowering right for patients. The Chronic Disease Self-Management Programme developed in the USA has been adopted in a number of countries and in the UK has been as adapted as the Expert Patients Programme. However, despite its potential as a layled empowering initiative, the Expert Patients Programme has been criticised as perpetuating the medical model and failing to reach those in most need. This paper revisits a critique of the Expert Patients Programme, and drawing upon a qualitative study seeks to explore whether the Expert Patients Programme enables empowerment or replicates traditional patterns of the patient–professional relationship. A grounded-theory approach was adopted utilising focus groups, in-depth interviews and participant observation. Data were analysed through the constant comparative method and the development of codes and categories. Conducted in the relatively affluent area of the south-east of England, this paper draws on data from 66 individuals with a chronic illness who were knowledgeable, active and informed. The study revealed a number of characteristics common to expert patients that were linked to a systematic, proactive and organised approach to self-management, a clear communication style and the ability to compartmentalise emotion. The study included participant observation of an Expert Patients Programme and a professional-led self-management course. The paradoxical nature of the Expert Patients Programme was revealed, for whilst there was evidence that it reinforced the medical paradigm, there was a concurrent acknowledgement and support for the subjective experience of living with a long-term condition. Furthermore, whilst the policy emphasis has been on individual empowerment within the Expert Patients Programme, there is some evidence that it may be triggering a health consumer movement.
Publication date
2007Published in
Health & Social Care in the CommunityPublished version
https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2524.2007.00701.xOther links
http://hdl.handle.net/2299/1979Metadata
Show full item recordRelated items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Physiotherapy for Patients with Sciatica Awaiting Lumbar Micro-Discectomy Surgery: a Nested, Qualitative Study of Patients’ Views and Experiences
Boote, Jonathan; Newsome, Ruth; Reddington, Michael; Cole, Ashley; Dimairo, Munya (2017-07-13)AbstractBackground and PurposeSciatica is a common clinical condition that can be extremely painful, disabling and life-changing. Whether conservative or surgical treatment for sciatica secondary to an intervertebral disc ... -
Intelligent Model-Based Advisory System for the Management of Ventilated Intensive Care Patients – Part I : Hybrid Blood Gas Patient Model
Wang, A.; Mahfouf, M.; Mills, G.H.; Panoutsos, G.; Linkens, D.A.; Goode, K.; Denai, Mouloud (2010-08)Arterial blood gas (ABG) analyses are essential for assessing the acid–base status and guiding the adjustment of mechanical ventilation in critically ill patients. Conventional ABG sampling requires repeated arterial ... -
Monitoring patients on methotrexate : hepatic fibrosis not seen in patients with normal serum assays of aminoterminal peptide of type III procollage
Maurice, P.D.L.; Maddox, A.J.; Green, C.A.; Tatnall, F.; Schofield, J.; Stott, D. (2005)Background: The aminoterminal peptide of type III procollagen (PIIINP) is formed during the synthesis of type III collagen and can be measured in the serum. It has been used as a marker for hepatic fibrosis in patients on ...