Moments of choice, agency and decision making in the narratives of childhood sexual exploitation survivors

Damhuis Boogers, Racheal (2026) Moments of choice, agency and decision making in the narratives of childhood sexual exploitation survivors. Doctoral thesis, University of Hertfordshire.
Copy

Background - This study explores how individuals with lived experiences of child sexual exploitation (CSE) narrate choices, decision-making, and agency within experiences shaped by coercion, vulnerability and broader structural pressures. Dominant frameworks, and some strands of the literature, have approached CSE through relatively fixed binary categories of victimhood, where young people are positioned either as passive victims or as complicit in their own exploitation. While these categories have increasingly been challenged in research and practice, there remains a limited understanding of the complexities of constrained decision-making in CSE contexts. A preceding systematic literature review identified a particular lack of research exploring how agency and decision-making are narratively constructed and understood within lived experiences of CSE. Methodology - A qualitative narrative methodology was utilised using dialectical narrative analysis (DNA). Semi-structured narrative interviews were completed with six participants who identified as having lived experiences of CSE. The analysis focused on tension, positioning, contradictions and the ways in which participants assigned meaning to their experiences over time. Attention was also paid to how narratives moved between past and present understandings of exploitation, responsibility, survival, and identity. Findings - Across the narratives, five recurring dialectical tensions emerged: choice and constraint; resistance and compliance; belonging and harm; past and present self; moral identity and stigma. Participants' narratives noted that decision-making was shaped by coercion, fear, structural and cultural expectations, and attempts to develop survival strategies. Actions were at times framed externally as ‘choices’; these appeared to function as attempts to reduce harm, maintain one's moral position, and regain some sense of control. Agency across the narratives was rarely described as unrestricted freedom. Rather, it was intertwined with accounts of vulnerability, coercion, survival strategies and retrospective meaning-making. Conclusions - Overall, the narratives in the study suggest that within CSE, agency may be more complex than binary framings of either unfettered choices or complete victimhood suggest. Rather, the research participants’ accounts narrated agency as something that was shaped by relationships, social factors, the need to survive and retrospective meaning-making. Participants' narratives highlight how attempts to survive and maintain one's own moral position could later be reinterpreted through the lenses of shame, resistance, protection, cultural and gendered expectations, and resilience. The findings support the importance of contextually sensitive and survivor-informed understandings of CSE that can allow space for contradictions and complexity without reducing lived experiences to a simplistic narrative of passivity or blame.


picture_as_pdf
22055725 Damhuis Boogers Racheal thesis final version.pdf
Available under Creative Commons: BY 4.0

View Download

EndNote BibTeX Reference Manager Refer Atom Dublin Core MODS METS Data Cite XML RIOXX2 XML MPEG-21 DIDL OpenURL ContextObject in Span ASCII Citation HTML Citation OpenURL ContextObject OPENAIRE
Export

Downloads