Development of a Core Outcome Set for Person-Centred Outcomes in End-of-Life in Critical Care (PEACE-COS)

Humphreys, Sally (2026) Development of a Core Outcome Set for Person-Centred Outcomes in End-of-Life in Critical Care (PEACE-COS). Doctoral thesis, University of Hertfordshire.
Copy

Background: Critical care end-of-life research employs a diverse range of outcomes, including clinical, composite, observer and proxy-reported. However, there is a lack of agreement on ‘what’ to measure in these studies, with limited emphasis on person-centred outcomes. Furthermore, outcomes are inconsistently reported, limiting the synthesis of evidence and the comparability of study findings. Aim: To develop a core outcome set (COS) for research evaluating end-of-life care (EoLC) in critical care. Methods: Following established COS methodology, a four-stage study was undertaken. A systematic review (Stage One) and a qualitative interview and focus group study (Stage Two) identified a long list of potential outcomes for consideration in the COS. An international two-round modified e-Delphi study (Stage Three) was conducted, where panellists (patient/family representatives, health professionals, and researchers) rated the importance of outcomes for inclusion on a 9-point Likert scale. Consensus for inclusion was defined a priori. Framework analysis was employed to systematically organise and interpret qualitative comments. An international consensus meeting was held with key stakeholders to reach a final consensus on the outcomes for inclusion and to ratify the COS (Stage Four). Participants: Sixteen health professionals participated in Stage Two. Eighty-four panel members from ten countries across five continents participated in Stage Three. Six patient/family representatives attended a pre-consensus meeting, and 14 stakeholders attended the consensus meeting (Stage Four). Results: Stage One identified 114 unique outcomes with Stage Two identifying 175 outcomes. Panellists rated 93 outcomes in Round One and 69 outcomes in Round Two. Consensus was achieved on the inclusion of 27 outcomes. Reasons an outcome was considered either critical or not critical for inclusion were attributed to 14 themes. Ten themes and 29 subthemes emerged from the reasons provided for score alterations between rounds, with the most common reasons being ‘human consequences’ and ‘importance’. Six outcomes were ratified for inclusion in the final COS: pain, respiratory distress, delirium, dignity, quality of death and dying, and quality of communication. Conclusion: This is the first study to develop a COS for EoLC in critical care. It has the potential to reduce future research waste by standardising outcome selection, reducing heterogeneity in study reporting, facilitating the comparability of findings, and improving research quality. Public Researcher Partners Contribution: Study design, public-facing study documents, participant engagement resources, and presentation of findings.


picture_as_pdf
Sally Humphreys Final Thesis (Amended without highlighting).pdf
Available under Creative Commons: BY 4.0

View Download

EndNote BibTeX Reference Manager Refer Atom Dublin Core OpenURL ContextObject Data Cite XML OPENAIRE HTML Citation RIOXX2 XML MPEG-21 DIDL METS OpenURL ContextObject in Span MODS ASCII Citation
Export

Downloads