University of Hertfordshire Research Archive

        JavaScript is disabled for your browser. Some features of this site may not work without it.

        Browse

        All of UHRABy Issue DateAuthorsTitlesThis CollectionBy Issue DateAuthorsTitles

        Arkivum Files

        My Downloads
        View Item 
        • UHRA Home
        • University of Hertfordshire
        • Masters Theses
        • View Item
        • UHRA Home
        • University of Hertfordshire
        • Masters Theses
        • View Item

        Should we accept the existence of numbers as abstract objects?

        View/Open
        Download fulltext (PDF, 389Kb)
        Author
        O'Sullivan, Jacob
        Attention
        2299/20188
        Abstract
        This paper argues that we should accept the existence of numbers as abstract objects. I begin by looking at the Indispensability Argument as a positive argument for the existence of mathematical objects. I look at various discussions that challenge the Indispensability Argument, most notably that we can dismiss the doctrine of Confirmational Holism by looking to an argument that we use figurative talk in science, such as idealisations. This is the argument that, like idealisations, mathematical objects are only used in scientific theories figuratively and as such their existence is not confirmed by the success of the scientific theories they are included in. In order for this objection to stand, it needs to explain what figurative uses are and so I look at Mathematical Fictionalism, which aims to explain these uses for mathematical statements. I look at Yablo’s fictionalism, as the strongest argument for explaining this, and explain how he hopes to dismiss our commitment to the existence of mathematical objects by arguing that they are ‘creatures of existential metaphor’. Finally, I raise issues with this explanation and conclude that, without further argument, the fictionalist position does not convincingly dismiss our commitment to the existence of mathematical objects and so we should accept the existence of numbers as abstract objects.
        Publication date
        2018-06-21
        Published version
        https://doi.org/10.18745/th.20188
        Other links
        http://hdl.handle.net/2299/20188
        Metadata
        Show full item record
        Keep in touch

        © 2019 University of Hertfordshire

        I want to...

        • Apply for a course
        • Download a Prospectus
        • Find a job at the University
        • Make a complaint
        • Contact the Press Office

        Go to...

        • Accommodation booking
        • Your student record
        • Bayfordbury
        • KASPAR
        • UH Arts

        The small print

        • Terms of use
        • Privacy and cookies
        • Criminal Finances Act 2017
        • Modern Slavery Act 2015
        • Sitemap

        Find/Contact us

        • T: +44 (0)1707 284000
        • E: ask@herts.ac.uk
        • Where to find us
        • Parking
        • hr
        • qaa
        • stonewall
        • AMBA
        • ECU Race Charter
        • disability confident
        • AthenaSwan